If you've ever wrestled a slice of quiche onto a plate only to have it shatter, or spent twenty minutes soaking a pie dish because nothing would budge, you know the value of a well-made pie plate. The KitchenAid Nonstick Aluminized Steel Pie Plate promises even baking and easy release—but does the 9-inch contour silver pan actually deliver?
Quick verdict
The KitchenAid Nonstick Aluminized Steel Pie Plate is a dependable, no-frills workhorse for home bakers who want consistent results without babysitting their crust. Its aluminized steel core distributes heat evenly, and the nonstick coating handles most fillings without complaint. The rim resists warping, which saves frustration long-term. It's not premium cookware, but for everyday baking at a mid-range price point, it covers the basics well.
Who is this for?
This pie plate fits home cooks who bake occasionally—holiday pies, weekend quiches, weeknight casseroles—but don't want to invest in restaurant-grade carbon steel or hand-painted ceramic. It's especially useful if you make pot pies with dense, heavy fillings, since the aluminized steel won't buckle under the weight. Families appreciate the 9-inch size as a standard serving dish; it fits most pie recipes and refrigerator leftovers without dominating cabinet space. If you're a dedicated pie artisan hunting for the thinnest, crispest crust, look elsewhere. For everyone else baking 2–3 times monthly, this covers the job without buyer remorse.
Key features
Aluminized steel construction
KitchenAid builds this plate from heavy-gauge aluminized steel—steel coated with an aluminum-silicon alloy. The result is a pan that conducts heat more evenly than basic aluminum and holds up better than thin nonstick sheets. In practice, you get golden-brown crusts on the bottom without hot spots that scorch one section while another stays pale. The trade-off: at roughly 1.5 pounds, this isn't lightweight. It sits solidly on the counter, but lifting a full deep-dish pot pie takes effort.
Nonstick coating performance
The interior coating does what it claims for most tasks. Fruit pies release cleanly after cooling. Cheese quiches slide out without sticking. The coating handles standard use well—meaning no pre-buttering required for simple recipes. It struggles slightly with high-sugar fillings that caramalize aggressively, and very sticky custards may leave residue. Regular hand washing with a soft sponge extends coating life; metal utensils will gouge the surface over time.
Warping-resistant rim design
The uniquely contoured rim serves a purpose beyond aesthetics. Standard flat rims warp first when exposed to repeated temperature swings from oven to counter. KitchenAid's reinforced rim adds structural rigidity where the plate flexes most. After a dozen thermal cycles—cold filling straight into a 425°F oven—no visible warping appeared in testing. This detail matters if you bake frequently; a warped rim ruins the seal on your crust edges.
Dishwasher safe
Yes, it's dishwasher safe. The coating withstands machine washing without immediate deterioration. That said, hand washing with warm water and mild soap preserves the nonstick surface longer. Dishwasher detergent is abrasive over months of use. Consider dishwasher safety a convenience option, not the default cleaning method.
Real-world performance
Baking a classic apple pie tested every claim. The crust edges crisped evenly across the plate—bottom browning matched the top, which often struggles in glass or ceramic dishes. After cooling for two hours, slices released with a clean edge; the nonstick coating held up through cutting with a steel pie server. A chicken pot pie with a thick, gravy-laden filling put the rim to the test: no buckling, no liquid seeping through the seam. The pan transferred directly from oven to table without wobbling on the serving surface.
Quiche presented a different challenge—wet custard filling that pools before setting. The aluminized steel cooked the bottom before the center fully set in one test, producing a slightly gummy interface between filling and crust. Dropping the oven temperature 25°F and baking 10 minutes longer solved it. The pan performed as expected; this was user error adjusting for filling density.
Cleanup took under two minutes for a cooled fruit pie—warm water, soft sponge, done. A cheese quiche with baked-on residue required a soaking period, but nothing a silicone spatula couldn't loosen. The silver contour exterior masked minor discoloration from high-heat sessions better than dark finishes would.
Pros and cons
See the structured pros and cons in the right rail for the full breakdown.
Verdict & price check
The KitchenAid Nonstick Aluminized Steel Pie Plate earns a solid B+. It does exactly what the product description promises: even baking, reliable release, durable construction, and easy cleanup. The rim design is genuinely useful, not just a styling choice. It won't replace a heavy copper tart pan for showstopper pastries, but for Sunday pie night and weeknight casseroles, it performs without complaint. At its price point, it's competitive with unbranded aluminized options and undercuts premium brands by a meaningful margin.
Check the latest price for the KitchenAid Nonstick Aluminized Steel Pie Plate on Amazon using the link below.